An advisor to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has issued a legal opinion stating that Ireland cannot use housing shortages as a justification for failing to accommodate single male asylum seekers.
The opinion, published Thursday by the Luxembourg-based court, indicates that Ireland “cannot use force majeure to justify failure to provide basic needs for international protection applicants.” It further states that even during “a large influx of people” applying for asylum, “member states cannot invoke force majeure to avoid responsibility for providing adequate reception conditions or compensating for harm caused.”
This development challenges a key argument used by the Irish government in an ongoing legal dispute. The Department of Children is currently appealing a High Court ruling from August that found the state in breach of fundamental rights by failing to provide accommodation to single male asylum seekers.
The case was brought by the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission following the department’s December 2023 decision to stop housing single male adults seeking asylum. Instead, these applicants were provided a weekly allowance of โฌ113.80 along with information about charities offering food and tents.
Since implementing this policy, 8,017 men have applied for asylum in Ireland. While over 5,000 have since received accommodation, 3,150 international protection applicants remained “awaiting offer of accommodation” as of Tuesday.
The question of whether force majeureโabnormal circumstances outside a state’s control whose consequences couldn’t be avoided despite due careโcould be invoked as a defense was referred to the ECJ by Ireland’s High Court last year.
ECJ Advocate General Laila Medina, who examined the issue, stated in her opinion that there is “a clear and unequivocal obligation on member states to provide applicants with adequate material reception conditions, including housing.” She emphasized this obligation “is not conditional on the scale of the influx of applicants; rather, it is an absolute requirement that must be met, regardless of the challenges faced by the member state.”
Medina further noted, “A large influx of applicants for international protection cannot, in itself, serve as a stand-alone defense of force majeure.” While member states have “some discretion in how they manage such influxes,” this is limited to “the modalities by which the basic reception conditions are provided” and does not extend to “derogating from the fundamental obligation to ensure that applicants’ human dignity is respected.”
Though not binding, the Advocate General’s opinion is likely to inform the final ECJ ruling.
The Irish Refugee Council welcomed the opinion, saying it underlined that “Ireland cannot avoid its obligations under EU law to provide for basic accommodation and means of subsistence for international protection applicants.”
The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission described the opinion as “important” as it stated the provision of accommodation was “an absolute requirement that must be met, regardless of the challenges faced by the member state.”
About the author
U.S. Strike on Yemen Fuel Port Results in Dozens of Casualties, According to Houthi Media
U.S. strikes on a fuel port in Yemen killed at least 58 people, according to Houthi-run Al Masirah TV, marking one of the deadliest attacks since the United States began its military campaign against the Iran-backed militants. The United States has stated it will not cease the large-scale strikes that began last monthโits most significant military operation in the Middle East since President Donald Trump took office in Januaryโunless the Houthis stop their attacks on shipping in the Red Sea. Al Masirah TV reported that Thursday's strikes on the western fuel port of Ras Isa also resulted in 126 wounded. The U.S. military characterized the operation as an effort to cut off a fuel source for the Houthi militant group. When Reuters requested comment regarding the casualty figures reported by the Houthis and the U.S. military's estimate, U.S. Central Command […]
Minister Jack Chambers Questioned Over Past Planning Objections Despite Recent Housing Comments
Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers, who recently criticized planning objections based on "character of an area" concerns, is facing scrutiny over his past objection to a development that included apartments. This week, Chambers announced measures to accelerate infrastructure delivery. He stated that objections based on neighborhood character are "nebulous" and block housing supply goals. He claimed there are "countless examples" of people trying to "frustrate" housing development for the "broad public good." However, records show that in 2016, Chambers objected to a mixed-use Lidl development in Castleknock that included eight apartments. As a local TD then, he argued the project would "compromise and constrain the aesthetic and visual outlook" of the village. During an An Bord Pleanala hearing in 2017, he reportedly described the development as a "monstrosity" that "puts an atomic bomb under the conservation area." In his […]
Hard-Right Allies at Odds: Meloni’s Diplomatic Tightrope Between Trump and the EU
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni faced a delicate diplomatic challenge during her White House visit as she attempted to balance her ideological alignment with President Trump against her responsibilities to the European Union. The relationship between the United States and the EU has grown increasingly strained under Trump's administration. Meloni, part of a newer generation of hard-right European leaders with connections to the Trump administration, has cultivated a personal rapport with the president, who has described her as "a real live wire" and a "fantastic woman." Her anti-immigration stance aligns with Trump's policies, earning her a reputation as someone who can effectively communicate with him. Meloni's visit comes amid widespread international concern over Trump's global tariff policies. Initially imposing a 20% tax on all EU goods entering the United States, Trump later reduced this to a 10% blanket rate following […]
Young Adults Face Highest Risk on Irish Roads as Easter Weekend Approaches
One in three people killed or seriously injured on Irish roads were under the age of 30, according to recent data shared by authorities ahead of the Easter weekend. An Garda Sรญochรกna and the Road Safety Authority are urging drivers to prioritize road safety during the holiday period. Police are launching an enhanced roads policing operation from 7 a.m. Friday until 7 a.m. Tuesday. Every available Garda member on duty throughout the long weekend will conduct road traffic enforcement activities, though officials emphasize that they "need the public's help" to prevent tragedies. "Anyone who is intending to socialize and have drinks at any point over the long weekend needs to leave their car at home, arrange a designated driver among friends, pre-book a taxi, use public transport where possible or fix up a lift home from someone they trust who […]
Golf Superstar’s Trophy Could Inspire Struggling Red Devils, Says Coach
Amorim Invites Masters Champion McIlroy to Bring Green Jacket to Old Trafford Manchester United manager Amorim has invited Rory McIlroy to bring his Masters Green Jacket to Old Trafford, hoping it might inspire his underperforming team. McIlroy, a United supporter who recently completed a career grand slam at Augusta National, had suggested he would take his Green Jacket to the stadium "if it can inspire some better play." Responding through Manchester United's official X account, Amorim welcomed the Northern Irishman: "Hi Rory. Congratulations for the Masters and I want to invite you to Old Trafford to show your trophy. It's really important for us in this moment. You achieved something that a lot of people thought would be impossible, and we want that feeling in our stadium. So I hope to see you soon at Old Trafford and to meet […]
MAJOR DRUG BUST: Over โฌ149k of Narcotics Seized in Dublin Raid
Gardaรญ have arrested a man following a significant drug seizure worth approximately โฌ149,100 in Ballymun, Dublin. On Tuesday morning, the Ballymun Divisional Drugs Unit conducted a search of premises in the area with support from the Armed Support Unit, Ballymun Detective Unit, and Ballymun Community Response Team. During the operation, authorities seized approximately โฌ87,500 of suspected heroin and โฌ61,600 of suspected cocaine. A man in his 30s was arrested in connection with the search and is currently being detained at a Garda station in North Dublin. The operation was part of an ongoing initiative targeting the sale and supply of drugs in the Dublin Metropolitan Region (DMR) North. A Garda spokesperson confirmed that investigations into the matter are continuing.
Related
US Senator Confronts Trump in Shock Visit to Deported Man in El Salvador Prison
A US senator has met with Kilmar รbrego Garcรญa, a man who Trump administration officials acknowledge was erroneously deported from Maryland to El Salvador's maximum-security prison. Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen shared photos of the meeting, which appeared to take place in a hotel, as the administration continues fighting against รbrego Garcรญa's return despite Thursday's court ruling against the government. Following the encounter, El Salvador's President Nayib Bukele stated the detainee would remain in the country's custody. The White House has accused รbrego Garcรญa of MS-13 gang membership, a designated foreign terrorist organizationโallegations his lawyer denies. Trump responded on Truth Social, saying Van Hollen "looked like a fool yesterday standing in El Salvador begging for attention from the Fake News Media, or anyone." The visit occurs amid an intensifying conflict between the president and the courts. On Thursday, the 4th […]
“US Gives Ukraine Peace Talks Final Deadline As Trump Threatens To Walk Away
The US will abandon efforts to broker a Russia-Ukraine peace deal within days unless clear progress emerges, according to US Secretary of State Marco Rubio. "We're not going to continue with this endeavour for weeks and months on end," Rubio stated, adding that the US had "other priorities to focus on." Russia, which launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, has placed various conditions on potential ceasefire terms. Despite the Trump administration's initial confidence in securing a quick agreement, ceasefire attempts have stalled, with Washington attributing blame to both sides. Following discussions with European leaders in Paris on Thursday, Rubio told reporters: "We need to determine very quickly now - and I'm talking about a matter of days - whether or not this is doable." He emphasized, "If it's not going to happen, then we're just going to move […]
U.S. Strike on Yemen Fuel Port Results in Dozens of Casualties, According to Houthi Media
U.S. strikes on a fuel port in Yemen killed at least 58 people, according to Houthi-run Al Masirah TV, marking one of the deadliest attacks since the United States began its military campaign against the Iran-backed militants. The United States has stated it will not cease the large-scale strikes that began last monthโits most significant military operation in the Middle East since President Donald Trump took office in Januaryโunless the Houthis stop their attacks on shipping in the Red Sea. Al Masirah TV reported that Thursday's strikes on the western fuel port of Ras Isa also resulted in 126 wounded. The U.S. military characterized the operation as an effort to cut off a fuel source for the Houthi militant group. When Reuters requested comment regarding the casualty figures reported by the Houthis and the U.S. military's estimate, U.S. Central Command […]
Minister Jack Chambers Questioned Over Past Planning Objections Despite Recent Housing Comments
Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers, who recently criticized planning objections based on "character of an area" concerns, is facing scrutiny over his past objection to a development that included apartments. This week, Chambers announced measures to accelerate infrastructure delivery. He stated that objections based on neighborhood character are "nebulous" and block housing supply goals. He claimed there are "countless examples" of people trying to "frustrate" housing development for the "broad public good." However, records show that in 2016, Chambers objected to a mixed-use Lidl development in Castleknock that included eight apartments. As a local TD then, he argued the project would "compromise and constrain the aesthetic and visual outlook" of the village. During an An Bord Pleanala hearing in 2017, he reportedly described the development as a "monstrosity" that "puts an atomic bomb under the conservation area." In his […]
Judge Rules Google Illegally Controls Online Ad Market As Tech Giant Faces Second Antitrust Defeat
A US judge has determined that Google maintains an illegal monopoly in online advertising technology, marking the tech giant's second antitrust loss within a year. The lawsuit, brought by the US Department of Justice and 17 states, successfully argued that Google illegally dominates the technology determining online ad placement. This ruling follows an earlier decision that found Google also held a monopoly in online search. Google has announced plans to appeal the decision. "Publishers have many options and they choose Google because our ad tech tools are simple, affordable and effective," stated Lee-Ann Mulholland, Google's head of regulatory affairs. In her ruling, US District Judge Leonie Brinkema declared Google had "wilfully engaged in a series of anticompetitive acts" allowing it to "acquire and maintain monopoly power" in the market. "This exclusionary conduct substantially harmed Google's publisher customers, the competitive process, […]
Trump Slams Fed Chair Powell For Not Cutting Interest Rates Fast Enough
Donald Trump has criticized Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell over interest rates, declaring on social media that Powell's "termination cannot come fast enough!" The president's remarks came ahead of the European Central Bank's (ECB) third interest rate cut this year. On Thursday, the ECB reduced its key rate, citing "rising trade tensions" as a factor. Trump, who appointed Powell as Fed chair in 2017 during his first term, wrote that Powell "is always TOO LATE AND WRONG" regarding rate reductions. He added: "Oil prices are down, groceries (even eggs!) are down, and the USA is getting RICH ON TARIFFS. Too Late should have lowered Interest Rates, like the ECB, long ago, but he should certainly lower them now." Contrary to Trump's claims, egg prices have actually increased to $6.23 per dozen according to official data, though oil prices have decreased […]
Be the first to leave a comment